Politics · Developing story
Appeals court rejects Justice Department request for California to set aside disputed ballots
NewsAgo briefing
The clear picture
What happened
A divided three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected the Justice Department’s request to have California set aside disputed ballots from a midterm election. CBS News says the court denied the request involving ballots received in California; The Hill puts the number at 20,000 ballots the administration says may have been cast by noncitizens.
Latest development
The 9th Circuit’s 2-1 ruling denied the Justice Department’s request, PBS NewsHour reports.
Why it matters
Al Jazeera reports that the court found the petition to remove 20,000 ballots from California’s count unconstitutional, preventing the requested removal at this stage. PBS NewsHour describes the decision as a setback to the Trump administration’s effort to exert control over elections run by states.
Known / unclear
The administration has alleged California sent ballots to some 20,000 people who may not be U.S. citizens.
The supplied accounts do not identify the election at issue, the panel’s judges, the reasoning beyond the constitutional characterization, the ballots’ verification status, or whether the Justice Department will seek further review.
NewsAgo wrote this briefing with an AI language model, using only the attributed reports listed below. Automated checks require every point to cite one of those reports and reject generic or unsupported text. How we use AI
Sources
Compiled from 4 independent publishers PBS NewsHour · Al Jazeera · CBS News · The Hill
The accounts agree that the 9th Circuit rejected the administration’s request. Al Jazeera says the court called removal of 20,000 ballots unconstitutional, while PBS NewsHour emphasizes the broader state-control issue; CBS News does not state a ballot total, and The Hill says the administration alleges the ballots were likely cast by noncitizens.
- PBS NewsHourAppeals court rejects Justice Department request for California to set aside disputed ballots ↗
- Al JazeeraUS appeals court again rejects Trump bid to set aside California ballots ↗
- CBS NewsAppeals court rejects DOJ bid to set aside disputed California ballots ↗
- The HillAppeals court rules against Trump — again — on California ballots ↗
- The HillAppeals court resists DOJ’s bid to immediately segregate 20k California ballots ↗
The big question
Will the 20,000 ballots remain in California’s vote count?
The reported ruling rejects the Justice Department’s request to set them aside; the supplied accounts do not establish whether any further appeal or separate verification process will follow.
What happens next
- Any Justice Department response to the 9th Circuit’s 2-1 decision.
- Whether California election officials take any further action concerning the 20,000 ballots identified in The Hill’s account.
Bottom line
The 2-1 ruling leaves California’s handling of the disputed ballots intact for now and marks another judicial rejection of the administration’s requested intervention.

Explore timelines and source history
Developing story: This developing story groups reporting from 4 publishers. The timeline shows how the coverage has changed.
What the coverage shows
Three or more independent publishers are reporting this development. Wording and emphasis may differ; open the source timeline to compare their reporting.
Compare the publisher timeline ↓Story evolution
- Development updated
The administration has alleged California sent ballots to some 20,000 people who may not be U.S. citizens.
3 sources at this update - Headline updated
The 2-1 ruling by the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals panel is the latest setback for the Trump administration's efforts to assert control over state-run elections.
4 sources at this update - Headline updated
The 9th Circuit Court called the petition to remove 20,000 ballots from California's vote count unconstitutional.
3 sources at this update - Headline updated
The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals rejected the Justice Department's request for California to set aside disputed ballots received in the midterm election.
1 source at this update - Headline updated
New reporting from The Hill: Appeals court resists DOJ’s bid to immediately segregate 20k California ballots.
1 source at this update